Score: 8

"OK, but a couple of the entries were worthless."

submission: MGS: Flash Collab DISC 01

date: July 11, 2008

Stamper's was a pile of crap and so was the one the appears i the load screen. The smoking ones and Lazymuffin's were great though.

Score: 8

"Cool stopmotion, um... are you dyslexic?"

submission: Army Men 2

date: April 28, 2008

I wantedto know because you misspell a lot of word in your titles. Like using "there" instead of "their" and also "soljure" instead of "soldier". You are pretty good at stop motion though I think your editing needs work. Like, when the timeline is paused at one image for 12 seconds. That is Ok when it i significant, but often you do it at unnessessary times. It seems like the video is lagging, but I can tell it isn't. Also, the pauses really screw up the pacing, which makes it more boring than I think it should actually be. If you save photos in PNG they don't appear as pixilated. If you just do that I think you will hav some really awesome stop motion. My potential greatness senses are tingling. 3 Hypothetical Pancakes out of 5 (4 if refined a bit more).

Score: 10

"Another masterpiece from Pro Fate and Doyvid"

submission: Engineered

date: April 28, 2008

I am amazed at how profound this is. You don't see flash like this every day on NG... unless you onl watch Pro-fate's videos that is. It is a great addition to his spectacular portfolio. The design of the film is solid and the story is heartbreakingly poignant. The graphics and animatiopn ae also awesome. I was very impressed by the sound work as well. Doyvid really outdid himself. Congrats on bing responcibl for such a wonderful achievment and thank for another amazing contribution o the portal. I give this 5 Hypothetical Pancakes out of 5.

Score: 10

"Greatness once again prevails!"

submission: Charlie the Unicorn 2

date: April 15, 2008

Awesome work typequeen, this is a historic flash moment!

Score: 10

"This could be a show on Adult Swim"

submission: Mastermind 3

date: April 4, 2008

I loved the artwork.Especialy the way you did the windows of the building on the menu. The red and black color scheme was cool without being inaccessable or depressing. The comedy was hilarious. Also it contained a ton of great animation. This is an extremely good submission. We could only expect such great work from the Swain. You know, I meant that he would only do good work and never bad work. No offense Adam Philups or Kelli Davis!

Score: 10

"I can't believe I got to be one the 1st to see it!"

submission: Radiohead - Creep

date: March 14, 2008

This deserves an academy award. No, I am serious, this is Oscar material. Yo could be the next Bill Plympton dude. I was incredibly inspired by this animation. The quality and beauty of it are astounding. You also have a veryinfectious art style. Yo really need t consider trying to sell this to MCR. I truly believe they would use this as a re-issue video. ANYONE who is reading this shuld not pain themselves anylonger to miss out on this fantastic example of tallent and ingenuity. I want to achieve this one day with my work it that is possible. I want to see this in the all time top fifty. I could not possibly have expected to have seen this when I clicked the WATCH button. Thank you for creating this amazing work of art!

Score: 10

"Good design, concept, but animation needs work."

submission: Alex Seryoua: Episode I

date: March 12, 2008

What I dislike a lot is when an artist has a great style and story, but relies on puppet and tween animation for their work. When you resort to that, you put yourself in a category of animators that has undertones of lazyness and lack of vision. This is by no means, a bad flash. I am just stating that it good be greatly improved by the simple addition of frame-by-frame animation. For yor artistic abilty, tweening just limits your work. The animation turns out cheesy and forgettable. Also, using multiple forms of animation and especially ones like FBF, that require hard work, will help you become a better artist. These are just a feww quibbles. I found this to be enigmatic and fascinating. If anyone reading is a fan of sci-fi and free NG sound effects, this is th flash for you.

Score: 10

"Subtle storytelling rivaling Hideaki Anno!"

submission: Animals

date: March 12, 2008

This is an amazing short. The art, design, color sceme and music all complement the message beautifully. It has a Spielburg/Anno quality that is touching as well as mesmerising. The black.red colorscheme was truly remarkable. You did a fantastic job.

From what I understand the story goes like this.
*The man's family dies
*He loses his religion
*He kills himself
*He is in purgatory
*He goes to heaven

Some of the reviewers thought he went to purgatory, then hell, but that would be impossible. People who go to hell don't want forgiveness. Everyone who ends up in purgatory, will eventually go to heaven. It may, though, take quite a while.

Anyway this is a fantastic existencial short and a testament to the ingenuity of Flash users.

Score: 1

"Rating is wrong !!! 18 AND UP"

submission: A Day To Remember

date: February 14, 2008

This is a gross misrepresentation of you artistic ability. Danman should be ashamed his work was included in this. Sorry, but its true.

Score: 10

"Very moving, beautiful."

submission: My Lost Valentine

date: February 14, 2008

Artistically, this was an excellent film. The message was touching and I found I could easily relate to it. The animation and action script were pretty solid too. This was a profound tribute. On the whole the only problem was that it was a bit short, but I feel it wasn't meant to be long or epic. I could never have guessed a user with a name like yours could create something this beautiful. Great work.